Buggy software and a lurchy transmission dampen our enthusiasm toward this otherwise appealing maxi Mini
We purchased a 2025 Mini Countryman S All4 for our vehicle test fleet. This small SUV is the Mini brand’s largest vehicle, and it has been thoroughly redesigned for 2025.
We know you can’t wait to hear what we think of it, so—as with all the cars we test—we’re sharing our initial hands-on impressions about the Countryman before we put it through our full regimen and give it a road-test score and an Overall Score.
Mini made the Countryman bigger in almost every dimension. It’s the largest Mini ever—about the same size as a Subaru Crosstrek. But unlike the plebeian Subie, the Mini tries to play in the entry-luxury space. It gets an exterior design that looks a bit like a shrunken Land Rover Defender and a fashionable interior with a unique circular touchscreen at the center of the dashboard.
For a model this size, it also boasts a shockingly roomy interior. A 312-hp John Cooper Works performance edition is also available, and an all-electric model is coming soon—we’ll test that as soon as we can purchase one. All three have standard all-wheel drive.
The Countryman has clearly reduced its reliance on nostalgia. That’s not such a bad thing: The Anglophile frills that defined the BMW-owned brand in the early 2000s were polarizing and as authentically British as Austin Powers.
Aside from the driver-selectable taillight motifs, which include a Union Jack design as one option, the new Countryman—built in Leipzig, Germany—has more mainstream appeal to compete on equal footing with the likes of the Audi Q3, Alfa Romeo Tonale, Jaguar E-Pace, Lexus UX, Mercedes-Benz GLA, Volvo XC40, and even the BMW X1 with which it shares an underlying platform.
Gone are fussy metal switches, reminiscent of British-made electronics from the 1960s that never worked quite right. They’ve been replaced by sleek German-made touchscreens that still don’t work quite right. In fact, the whole car feels a bit unfinished. We don’t yet know how that will affect our final judgment of the Countryman, but we plan to spend a lot more time with it to find out.